Even two years after the disappearance of fraudster Melissa Caddick, questions proceed to swirl concerning the circumstances of her mysterious disappearance and her loss of life.
Conwoman disappeared from her house in Sydney’s japanese suburbs on the morning of November 2020, only a day after police and company regulators raided her Dover Heights house.
The 49-year-old was accused of extorting $20 to 30 million from traders, together with her family and friends, in a Ponzi scheme.
This month, a coronation investigation investigated her closing actions, the police investigation, theories about her destiny and what a police officer mentioned within the investigation was “extraordinarily unusual and strange conduct” by her husband, Anthony Colletti.
Louise Coleman, a lawyer aiding the coroner, informed the court docket final week that officers concerned within the 2020 investigation suspected Colletti was concerned within the disappearance of Ms. Caddick.
The court docket was informed that Mr Coletti didn’t give an announcement to the police till 13 November, by which era his spouse had been lacking for greater than 24 hours.
“It’s clear from the temporary description of the proof that as early as 13 November 2020, every of the three law enforcement officials who had come to Mr. Coletti’s home that day and subsequently spoke with Witness B, offered by Mr. Coletti have been involved concerning the accounts and suspected he could have been concerned indirectly in Ms Caddick’s disappearance,” Ms Coleman mentioned.
Sergeant Trent Riley, who is because of present proof within the investigation, mentioned in a July 2021 assertion that he believed Mr Colletti knew of Ms Caddick’s whereabouts.
“He mentioned that Mr Coletti had informed him many lies, that his story had been modified a number of instances, and that he made ‘bizarre and strange feedback about numerous features of his model,’” Ms Coleman mentioned.
Nonetheless, any suggestion that Mr Colletti had gone lacking or was concerned within the attainable loss of life of his spouse was shortly denied.
He was the officer accountable for the investigation for a quick interval of 10 days in November 2020 earlier than being changed by Detective Sergeant Michael Kainur.
Throughout his time accountable for the investigation, Sergeant Kaynoor mentioned he thought-about three prospects – that he was killed by Coletti, that Ms Caddick had dedicated suicide, or that she had fled.
Nonetheless, he mentioned he dismissed the speculation that Mr Coletti, a hairdresser and part-time DJ, was concerned within the dishonesty.
Sergeant Kayanur mentioned it was “not a viable proposition” in his thoughts that he was killed by Mr Colletti.
“Whereas there was no proof of any battle or violence in the home, I used to be aware that (Ms Caddick’s son) was current on the time of her departure,” Sergeant Kaynoor mentioned.
Mr Coletti has not been charged with any offense associated to his disappearance.
Detective Sergeant Michael Foscolo informed the court docket he discovered “no proof to assist the speculation” that Colletti performed a job in Ms Caddick’s disappearance.
Ms Caddick’s household jumped to Mr Coletti’s protection, together with her brother saying he was “flooring” that counselors have been “following” him.
Grimley wrote in an announcement, “I make this assertion in response to a lawyer-assisted line of questioning that means that my brother-in-law, Anthony Colletti, could have brought on hurt to my sister, or indirectly brought on her to go lacking.” is concerned in.” Court docket on 19 September
“Anthony is enormously harmed not solely by the shock of Melissa’s loss and Melissa’s misconduct, but in addition by the unfounded allegations made by sure sections of the media, now being pursued by the legal professional aiding on this investigation.”
The investigation reported that Ms Caddick’s household held ASIC accountable for her loss of life, claiming she was not supplied meals or drink in the course of the raid on 12 November – though video of the court docket search contained Ms Caddick’s criticism. No indication of is proven.
Isabella Allen, ASIC’s principal investigator within the case, informed the court docket that Ms Caddick’s brother had accused her of inflicting the fraudster’s loss of life.
The court docket heard Mr Grimley ask Ms Allen in June 2021: “How do you’re feeling about being accountable for Melissa’s loss of life?”
“Do you’re feeling accountable?” She was requested by her lawyer, John Sutton.
“No, I used to be doing my job,” replied Ms. Allen.
Mr Colletti has additionally alleged that ASIC has been held accountable for his loss of life.
In an affidavit given by Mr Colletti in July 2021, he mentioned he believed Ms Caddick “died as a direct results of ASIC’s negligence, cruelty and inhumanity”, in the course of the raid on the pair. Accused of refusing meals, water and medical consideration.
Of his music, launched underneath the identify “Pause Off” and performed in court docket, he claimed in a single observe: “Simply ready for a coroner’s report to inform me one thing I already know, my spouse. died as a direct results of the ASIC investigation.”
The court docket is informed that in the course of the raid Ms. Caddick drank a protein shake, Mr. Coletti made a number of coffees for her, and that they sometimes smoked cigarettes within the yard of their Dover Heights house.
Requested whether or not he nonetheless mentioned that ASIC was accountable for his loss of life, Mr Colletti mentioned he did.
psychological well being
Forensic psychiatrist Dr. Kerry Eagles informed the court docket on Thursday she thought Ms. Caddick had narcissistic persona dysfunction after reviewing her medical data and witness statements.
Dr Eagles informed the court docket that on account of the allegations being made, Ms Caddick would have seen herself at risk of dropping the “respect and admiration” of her work, family members and others.
She informed the court docket, “The ASIC investigation will in the end be a public and private humiliation, costing her friendship, damaging her household relationships and destroying her present way of life.”
“Provided that she seems to measure her personal self-worth largely via the perceptions of others, this ends in a major narcissistic harm to her vanity and doubtlessly a disastrous type of disgrace and despair.” degree.”
Dr. Eagles mentioned that individuals with related problems have been identified to take their very own lives after a “nice insult to their vanity”.
“If Ms Caddick ended her life, the choice might have been impulsive, fueled by emotions of intense disgrace and hopelessness arising from the circumstances,” she mentioned.
Beneath questioning from John Sutton, the lawyer representing Ms Allen, Mr Colletti agreed that it was “doubtless” that he took his personal life after realizing that he had misplaced his life.
Ms Caddick is suspected to be useless after the stays of her leg have been discovered on a seaside in Tathra on the NSW south coast in February 2021, three months after she went lacking.
An oceanographer informed the court docket that it was attainable that his physique had gone into the water in Dover Heights on the morning of his disappearance and was washed away 400 km from the shore months later.
Dr David Griffin mentioned his physique might swim near sea degree for about 93 days earlier than resurfacing in February 2021.
The court docket earlier heard throughout interrogation that the police thought-about an experiment involving dumping pig carcasses into the ocean at one stage, trainers and monitoring units.
The plan was to check ocean currents and the way sharks would react.
Detective Sergeant Steven Morgan informed the court docket he didn’t know whether or not he ever did the experiment.
The remainder of Ms Caddick’s physique was by no means discovered.
initially revealed Inquest hears theories about what occurred to lacking fraudster Melissa Caddick