Texas A&M coach Jimbo Fisher knew what he was doing. As the ultimate seconds of an Orange Bowl victory following the 2020 season ticked away, Fisher gave a little bit fist pump earlier than he started to go searching defensively.
As Fisher jogged to midfield he noticed what he was searching for: gamers holding a Gatorade jug, charging towards him. Displaying a burst of velocity, Fisher outran the would-be inexperienced tub, and despite the fact that the hassle resulted in a little bit of a limp, the massive grin on his face remained.
The Aggies appeared on the cusp of breaking by way of after the 41-27 victory over North Carolina and a No. 4 rating to finish the pandemic-shortened season, their highest rating since 1939. To this present day, Fisher insists they have been the second-best crew within the nation and may have made the School Soccer Playoff. Nothing will persuade him in any other case.
Whereas that nice debate will dwell on in Texas A&M lore, what was not up for dialogue on Jan. 2, 2021 was this: The Aggies appeared prepared to interrupt into school soccer’s most rarefied air, fulfilling the large expectations that got here with handing Fisher an unprecedented 10-year, $75 million contract just some years earlier than.
“I am gonna let you know this,” Fisher stated after the Orange Bowl victory. “We ain’t executed but.”
Since then, nevertheless, issues have began to unravel. Texas A&M has opened every of the previous two seasons ranked No. 6 within the preseason polls and is barely 11-6 over that point. It’s at the moment unranked, following losses to Appalachian State and Mississippi State, and heads into Tuscaloosa on Saturday (8 p.m. ET, CBS) to face No. 1 Alabama at a disappointing 3-2.
All of a sudden, a recreation that after seemed like a possible top-10 showdown and the primary assembly of Fisher and Saban since their offseason disagreement has taken on a really totally different that means. The Aggies are dropping video games they should not, Fisher’s offense is the first wrongdoer and his post-Orange Bowl contract extension means his buyout will stay above $50 million till 2027, per USA At present. It has left some in School Station questioning whether or not they’re getting sufficient return for his or her hefty funding.
Fisher declined an interview for this story, however his boss believes he’ll flip it round.
“Look, Jimbo is an offensive innovator,” Texas A&M athletic director Ross Bjork stated. “He is all the time tailored to the model of play. When it is clicking on all cylinders, it really works and it is confirmed to work. So we simply should hold maturing, hold getting higher. And clearly, we’ll hold recruiting at a excessive degree.”
FISHER EARNED THAT popularity Bjork talked about first as an assistant at LSU after which as head coach at Florida State. Quarterbacks JaMarcus Russell, EJ Manuel, Christian Ponder and Jameis Winston have been all first-round picks after beginning a number of seasons for Fisher. His Seminoles went 26-1 with Winston because the starter, received a nationwide title in 2013 and made the School Soccer Playoff in 2014.
However that appears like a lifetime in the past in school soccer, lengthy earlier than NIL and the switch portal, and again when Nick Saban nonetheless relied on protection and ball management to win video games. When Saban employed Lane Kiffin as his offensive coordinator in 2014 it was to maintain up with the altering occasions. Because of this, he stored his dynasty rolling by recruiting and creating future Heisman contenders and first-round picks at quarterback seemingly yearly.
That is an space the place Fisher has fallen brief lately. From 2015 to ’22, the post-Winston period, Fisher’s quarterbacks have mixed for a median Complete QBR of 66.5, which ranks thirty eighth amongst FBS head coaches to educate a minimum of 40 video games throughout that span.
Between 2013 and 2017, the Seminoles signed seven quarterbacks. Just one completed his profession with Florida State. At Texas A&M, Fisher has been a prodigious recruiter — his top-ranked 2022 class is likely one of the highest rated ever– signing and creating blue-chip expertise everywhere in the area.
However thus far, that elite expertise has not panned out at quarterback.
In School Station, Fisher has signed 5 signal-callers. James Foster and Zach Calzada, in Fisher’s first two recruiting lessons at Texas A&M, have already transferred. Haynes King, the No. 4 twin menace quarterback within the class of 2020, misplaced his beginning job to switch Max Johnson after the App State loss, although he was pressed into responsibility once more this weekend when Johnson was injured, throwing two interceptions after coming off the bench. The Aggies are nonetheless very excessive on freshman Conner Weigman, the No. 1 quarterback within the 2022 ESPN 300, with Fisher saying Monday he may play now and be comfy.
This yr, Texas A&M ranks a hundred and fifth of 131 groups in complete offense (335 yards per recreation) and 108th in scoring offense (21.8 factors per recreation). There aren’t many vibrant spots: a hundred and first in passing offense, 98th in speeding offense, 96th in first downs, 79th in completion share, one hundred and fifteenth in time of possession and final — 131st — in performs run per recreation (56.4). Requested in regards to the struggles after scoring 24 factors within the Mississippi State loss, Fisher doubled down, saying his system nonetheless works.
“That system is similar system lots of people use. The performs are there,” Fisher stated. “We’re simply not executing.”
“I feel the error individuals make is saying, ‘Boy, that is outdated,'” stated former Florida coach Dan Mullen, now an ESPN analyst. “There isn’t any excellent system. Possibly extra of the problem is he has to adapt to his present roster, which he went and recruited all this velocity and all these athletes on offense, and he is received to have the system that matches these guys.”
No less than one prime recruit agrees with that final half.
“Right here is the distinction between Texas and Texas A&M,” Cook dinner stated. “Proper now, Texas has the scheme however not the gamers, A&M has the gamers however not the scheme. I imply A&M is working just like the Wishbone offense. It is cool and all, but when Jimbo opened it up that will be critical.”
Cook dinner is only one participant. However he was an A&M goal who dedicated to the rival Longhorns. Nonetheless, Fisher landed Evan Stewart, the No. 2 WR and No. 13 general recruit within the 2022 class and Chris Marshall, the No. 4 receiver.
Whereas Fisher continues to signal elite large receivers, he has had solely three drafted in his 12 years as a head coach, together with only one within the first 4 rounds. At Texas A&M, his receivers have struggled to place up numbers, both due to points at quarterback or the intricacies of the system.
Manuel stated it isn’t that the offense is overly advanced; it’s that there’s a methodology to the way in which Fisher needs it run. All of it begins with the quarterback, who has to not solely learn and establish the protection to ensure the offense is ready for achievement. He should additionally make the right safety requires the offensive line, an obligation that usually goes to the middle.
As soon as quarterbacks are totally comfy understanding what Fisher needs and the way it ought to look, then all the pieces turns into simpler. Ponder, Manuel and Winston all redshirted at Florida State. So did Fisher’s final beginning quarterback with the Seminoles, Deondre Francois, who had the very best QBR of any of Fisher’s QBs since Winston (78.0).
“The ideas that he has together with his offense, if you happen to can determine them out and keep on with them, you are going to have success as a result of he lays all the pieces on the market for you,” Manuel stated. “It is not simple, however when you do it, it is like, ‘OK, let’s go, I received this.’ Make no mistake — it is a skilled soccer offense, and it is not for everyone. However the guys that may determine it out can have success.”
Over the previous decade, the highschool recreation has developed and QB-friendly schemes just like the Air Raid — which numerous Texas excessive faculties run — do not require a lot of these nuances. As an alternative, there’s a deal with simplification — the quarterback within the shotgun, seeking to the sideline for the decision. However Fisher has not simplified something. He firmly believes in what he does with quarterbacks and his offense.
But when quarterbacks arising in unfold offenses should not in a position to instantly deal with all the pieces Fisher needs his quarterbacks to do, and it takes a QB a number of years to actually grasp the ideas, does Fisher’s method nonetheless make sense within the switch portal period?
FOR THOSE WHO consider in Fisher’s pro-style offense, they will level to scoring 41 factors in an upset win over Alabama final yr, however much more importantly to that 9-1 season in 2020.
That offense cast Texas A&M with a brand new id. Gone have been the second-half swoons that had change into a working joke amongst A&M’s detractors. This was a bodily, robust, old-school SEC crew. The 2020 Aggies led the SEC in yards per rush (5.5) and time of possession and ranked fourth within the nation in fewest sacks per go try, permitting simply 4 sacks all season. Senior quarterback Kellen Mond, a four-year starter, was extremely environment friendly, and the Aggies transformed 55% of their third downs, third finest nationally.
“For those who simply have a look at 2020, I do not suppose anybody had any offensive complaints,” Bjork stated. “Ball management, transfer the ball, explosive performs, all these issues have been there. There’s an evolution proper? When you could have new quarterbacks, it doesn’t matter what degree, there is a transition. When you could have a Kellen Mond the place you have received expertise, and you then transition to new quarterbacks, that takes adjustment. This yr, similar factor. Haynes King did not have a lot expertise. Then now, Max [Johnson] has received a little bit extra expertise. So that you’re possibly seeing a little bit extra poise.”
This yr, the offensive line that was so stout in 2020 has confronted points, complicating these quarterback transitions. The Aggies have confronted stress on 39% of their QB dropbacks, second worst within the FBS behind solely Boston School (41%).
Fisher shuffled his offensive workers’s duties earlier than fall camp. Offensive coordinator Darrell Dickey, who additionally coached quarterbacks, was moved to tight ends, and is now co-OC with James Coley, who moved from tight ends to large receivers. Dameyune Craig, who had been WR coach since arriving from FSU with Fisher, now coaches the quarterbacks alongside him.
Bjork has heard the questions questioning if Fisher has an excessive amount of on his plate to deal with playcalling. When Fisher has been requested about whether or not he would think about giving up playcalling duties, he says he “probably may,” but it surely’s unclear who on the prevailing workers would tackle that function, particularly after the adjustments in duties.
“I do not see that,” Bjork stated. “There’s head coaches that decision performs everywhere in the nation. And that is simply how Jimbo is constructed. He needs to be within the offense. He needs to work with the quarterbacks. That is his forte. That is why he was employed, and that is why we prolonged him as a result of he is received that in him.”
FORMER GEORGIA COACH Mark Richt is one other fan of Fisher’s method to teaching quarterbacks. He was on the Miami-Texas A&M recreation in September to look at Johnson, his nephew, make his first begin for the Aggies. Richt stated one of many causes Johnson selected to switch from LSU to Texas A&M was to study below Fisher.
“That a part of the sport is de facto his energy, the extra you possibly can placed on him to achieve a bonus on the sphere, the higher for Max,” Richt stated. “Jimbo is difficult on them dudes, but it surely’s not private. He is arduous on all these guys.”
One other coach who has competed towards Fisher doesn’t suppose the Aggies’ points stem from Fisher additionally serving as the first playcaller. Although the papers and notebooks Fisher has in his arms on the sideline have change into the butt of jokes, the opposing coach famous, “The man has one million performs that his guys execute that they do not even present. That is wonderful to me. I do not know what all their issues are. However I feel anytime you could have a extremely ranked recruiting class, and you then’re not measuring as much as that, individuals are going to begin throwing stones.”
However others are simply puzzled by the outcomes, saying the difficult system introduces too many issues with the sheer quantity of expertise readily available, that each one these name sheets and notebooks are an indicator Fisher is simply attempting to do an excessive amount of from years of data he has picked up as a playcaller at a number of stops. One coach stated the stress to interrupt out of a droop can typically trigger coaches to dig too deep within the playbook as an alternative of pulling again. He stated that is what he sees watching Fisher name a recreation.
“As a younger coach, Tom Osborne gave me a chunk of recommendation I by no means forgot,” a longtime offensive coordinator stated. “He stated, ‘When occasions get robust — and they’re going to — get out your eraser, not your pencil.'”
A Energy 5 head coach agreed, saying there’s approach an excessive amount of expertise readily available for the offense to be so dysfunctional.
“Simplicity is what makes nice offenses. The flexibility to execute,” he stated. “I feel that is their subject. I flip the movie on and I am not fairly positive what they’re attempting to do. It’s a must to have an id and it’s a must to have one thing you could financial institution on. And I simply do not see that they’ve that. I understand how good all these gamers are. No one can see behind the veil, but it surely’s simply arduous for me to ascertain you could’t line up and run the ball towards Appalachian State. I actually consider in the event that they ran 4 performs the entire recreation — two passes and two runs — I feel they win by 40.”
All that expertise is a reminder of certainly one of Fisher’s strengths: He can recruit. He is aware of how he needs to construct a program, stockpiling expertise alongside each the offensive and defensive strains and touchdown uncommon working again skills, comparable to Devon Achane, who was the MVP of that Orange Bowl as a freshman and led the SEC in yards per carry (7.0) final yr. He’ll have expertise. He is an old-school coach who places gamers within the NFL. The irony is Fisher’s trademark is the one space that appears to be holding again the Aggies. In the event that they’re ever going to problem for nationwide titles, that is the one space that calls for probably the most enchancment.
Each Alabama and Georgia thrived as soon as they modified their offenses.
“I keep in mind him saying, ‘I really feel like our offense is a Lamborghini, but it surely’s headed off a cliff,’ that means we have got these nice gamers however are behind the occasions in what we’re doing,” Kiffin instructed ESPN final yr about his first assembly with Saban after he was employed. “So we wanted to alter instructions.”
The Crimson Tide made the School Soccer Playoff recreation six of the next eight seasons.
After a 2019 season when Georgia averaged simply 21.5 factors per recreation over a six-game stretch of SEC video games, then scored simply 10 within the SEC title recreation towards LSU, Kirby Good employed Todd Monken to take over for Coley, who was serving as offensive coordinator (he left a month later to hitch Fishers’ workers). Final yr, the Bulldogs received their first nationwide championship in 41 years with Stetson Bennett, a former walk-on, at QB because the Bulldogs averaged 38.6 factors per recreation.
Nonetheless, Mullen stated it is simpler for coaches like Saban and Good to make offensive adjustments, as a result of their careers have been spent on the defensive aspect. For an offensive coach, calling your personal performs as a head coach continues to be a supply of delight, though that makes the goal in your again even greater.
Bjork believes the season continues to be a piece in progress. However he anticipates working along with Fisher to deal with any future points.
“What are the issues that this system must be profitable?” Bjork stated. “If that includes making adjustments, implementing new concepts, there’s all the time ongoing conversations about all these issues. Coach Fisher and I’ve an ideal relationship from that perspective. We discuss on a regular basis in regards to the state of this system or what’s wanted or what adjustments he may be enthusiastic about. As I am involved for this yr, 2022, this script just isn’t even written but. Coach is aware of how you can win at a excessive degree. He is aware of that if changes should be made, he is gonna make the proper of changes and people issues all happen throughout a relentless analysis. It is an evolution.”
That begins Saturday towards the Crimson Tide. Can Fisher pull off one other stunner, like when he turned the primary Saban assistant to beat the grasp final yr? Or will the Crimson Tide additional add to the Aggies’ distress?
“I do suppose he’s below stress on this system taking the subsequent step,” Mullen stated. “That is the place numerous the stress comes from saying, ‘Hey, that is 12 months 5. You have had some actually good recruiting lessons. Are we going to see you at 10 or 11 wins this yr? In November, are you within the combine for the SEC title recreation?’ These are questions that folks need answered.”